Tuesday November 28, 2023
  • Venezuela
  • Mexico
  • Colombia
  • Chile
  • Brazil
  • Argentina
  • Podcast
Versión Español
PanAm Post
  • Home
  • Regions
    • South America
    • North America
    • Central America
    • Caribbean
  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Authors
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Regions
    • South America
    • North America
    • Central America
    • Caribbean
  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Authors
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
PanAm Post
No Result
View All Result

Home » Costa Rica’s Cigarette-Tax Regime a Gift to Black Markets

Costa Rica’s Cigarette-Tax Regime a Gift to Black Markets

David Rodríguez Suárez by David Rodríguez Suárez
July 30, 2014
in Central America, Columnists, Costa Rica, Economics, Free Markets, Opinion
FacebookTwitterTelegramWhatsapp

EspañolFranklin Murillo, the manager of British American Tobacco in Costa Rica, told La Nación on March 31 that “In the face of higher taxes on a legal product … an illicit market will arise that does not compete under equal conditions and provides products at lower prices and lower quality.”

This is a phenomenon that merits our attention. Since the enactment of the Anti-Tobacco Law in Costa Rica on March 2012, we’ve been under the impression that cigarette use has gone down. However, in reality, we’ve seen a dramatic increase in illegal smuggling, and all because of a lack of understanding of how the market works.

RelatedArticles

The night Chris Rock turned into a 12-year-old whiny bully victim

The night Chris Rock turned into a 12-year-old whiny bully victim

March 26, 2023
The new socialist supremacisms: a maoist cultural revolution undermines the US

The new socialist supremacisms: a maoist cultural revolution undermines the US

August 21, 2021

In Costa Rica, it was thought that if taxes on cigarettes were increased, no one would buy them anymore because of higher prices. People failed to realize that doing this would only lead to tobacco users turning to the black market. Instead of taxing cigarettes at a lower rate, and therefore taxing a larger quantity of sales, the government failed to properly analyze the situation.

La Nación points out that in 2013, Costa Rican authorities seized nine times more smuggled cigarettes than in 2012. This is undoubtedly a result of the increased tax.

From September, the Ministry of Health will require cigarette packaging to contain repulsive images that depict the consequences of smoking. They ignore, of course, that these policies have proved to have minimal impact, as a result systematic desensitization. Even still, there are those who believe the only solution is to eliminate the product from the market entirely, forgetting that tobacco is one of the most important industries in the Costa Rican economy.

In response to the current policy direction in Costa Rica, Guillermo Oliva, director of Costa Rican Tobacco Corporate Affairs, cites Panama as a cautionary example: “With the excessive increase in cigarette taxes implemented in 2009, our neighbors not only failed to reach their public-health objectives, they also put tax collection in jeopardy by driving the industry to the brink of collapse.”

Therefore, there are certain things that must be considered when debating the issue of tobacco use.

    1. If we want to reduce consumption, focus should be placed on demand, and not on supply.
    2. Reducing demand is going to require more than simple behavior modification.
    3. The government does not benefit from a precipitous fall in consumption, given dependence on consumption for a revenue stream.
    4. It is preferable for the treasury if the use of tobacco stays legal, instead of illegal.
    5. The government fights against cigarette use, but also depends on it financially.

I point these out in order to illustrate the problem. It’s necessary to weigh the impact of smoking on public health with the tax revenue this activity generates. Far from issuing any sort of value judgement on cigarette smoking, my aim is to simply shed light on this issue. We cannot measure the real impact of the Anti-Tobacco Law, because much of the tobacco use has gone underground.

In reality, solutions to these kinds of health issues go beyond archaic prohibition methods. As a psychology student, I can say that there are many reasons why someone would start smoking, and they occur in an environment where not all variables can be controlled.

The desire to smoke can come from “emotional emptiness,” low self-esteem, irrational ideas, various reinforcements, social learning, among many other causes. Breaking this habit requires more than arbitrary government policy and demands from a centralized authority.

What the market does is satisfy demand. If the state assumes a repressive position against legal producers … the only ones who will benefit, in the end, are the illegal producers.

Translated by Pablo Schollaert.

Tags: CigarettetaxesTobacco
David Rodríguez Suárez

David Rodríguez Suárez

David Rodríguez Suárez is a psychology student at the Latin University of Costa Rica and president of youth outreach for the Libertarian Movement Party. Follow @DaveRodriguezS.

Related Posts

The night Chris Rock turned into a 12-year-old whiny bully victim
Columnists

The night Chris Rock turned into a 12-year-old whiny bully victim

March 26, 2023
The new socialist supremacisms: a maoist cultural revolution undermines the US
Columnists

The new socialist supremacisms: a maoist cultural revolution undermines the US

August 21, 2021
GETTR: the powerful weapon of Trump and international right wing
United States

GETTR: the powerful weapon of Trump and international right wing

July 13, 2021
Three Signs That Elon Musk Has the World at His Fingertips
Columnists

Trump Against Suppression of Human Rights

February 1, 2021
China Plans to Launch ‘Crypto-Yuan’ to Bolster Communist Regime’s Control
Asia

China Plans to Launch ‘Crypto-Yuan’ to Bolster Communist Regime’s Control

January 15, 2021
Purchase of Damaged Dollar Bills Is the Latest Unusual Business in Venezuela
Venezuela

Purchase of Damaged Dollar Bills Is the Latest Unusual Business in Venezuela

January 14, 2021
Next Post
Peru and Honduras Drop Visa Requirements for Tourists

Colombia, Panama Fail to Resolve Protective Tariff Conflict

Subscribe free and never miss another breaking story

  • Venezuela
  • Mexico
  • Colombia
  • Chile
  • Brazil
  • Argentina
  • Podcast

© 2020 PanAm Post - Design & Develop by NEW DREAM GLOBAL CORP. - Privacy policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Regions
    • South America
    • North America
    • Central America
    • Caribbean
  • Politics
  • Economics
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Authors
  • Contact

© 2020 PanAm Post - Design & Develop by NEW DREAM GLOBAL CORP. - Privacy policy

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Privacy and Cookie Policy.